Paesello's Pizzeria Menu

Paesello's Pizzeria, a beloved family-run Italian gem in Goshen, is known for authentic flavors and quality. Their menu stands out with classic dishes like Spaghetti with Meatballs, which offers rich, savory sauce paired with perfectly al dente pasta. The Combination Pizza and Gluten Free Cheese Pizza cater to diverse tastes, ensuring everyone finds a favorite. Freshness shines in their Greek Salad, dressed with house-made vinaigrette, balancing crisp vegetables and tangy flavors. The Italian Beef Sandwich and Onion Peppers and Sausage Pizza deliver bold, hearty options, while their Focaccia adds a delightful rustic touch. Customers praise the perfectly baked crust, generous mozzarella, and well-balanced toppings—each bite reflecting care and tradition. Though currently takeout only, the consistent quality and warm service create a memorable dining experience. Whether craving classic subs or standout salads, Paesello's offers something genuine and satisfying, making it a trusted staple for Italian cuisine lovers in Elkhart County.