Paesello's Pizzeria

Nestled in the heart of Goshen, Indiana, Paesello's Pizzeria is a cherished family-owned restaurant known for delivering an authentic Italian dining experience through takeout. Specializing in classic Italian and pizza dishes, Paesello’s is a go-to destination for those craving true, comforting flavors without the frills of full-service dining.

Their menu is an inviting celebration of Italian favorites, each item crafted with care and rich, satisfying flavors. The Spaghetti with Meatballs is a standout, featuring tender pasta bathed in a robust tomato sauce complemented by hearty, flavorful meatballs. For a fresh contrast, the crisp and vibrant Greek Salad brings bright Mediterranean notes to the table, perfectly balancing the richness of their heavier dishes.

Pizza lovers will find themselves spoiled for choice. From the savory Combination Pizza loaded with generous toppings to the thoughtfully prepared Gluten-Free Cheese Pizza that appeals to those with dietary needs, Paesello’s crust is consistently described as cooked to perfection — thin yet satisfying, with just the right crunch and chewy texture. Each pizza boasts a luscious layer of mozzarella paired with a flavorful sauce that lingers delightfully on the palate.

Beyond pizza, the menu is peppered with tempting options like the Italian Beef Sandwich and the delightfully seasoned Onion Peppers and Sausage Pizza, which blend bold, savory flavors with fresh, quality ingredients. Don’t miss their homemade Focaccia and crisp Salad Dressings, which complete the experience with thoughtful touches that remember old-world Italian food traditions.

Though now takeout-only, Paesello’s Pizzeria exudes a warm, approachable vibe that transcends the physical space—thanks largely to the genuine hospitality from the owner and staff. Frequent customers rave not just about the impeccable food but also the heartfelt service. Reviewers like Brad Gorgas and Fred Martin highlight the owner’s integrity and the staff’s cordiality, which make ordering feel personal and reliable every time.

What truly resonates is the consistent quality and authentic taste that have made Paesello’s a beloved fixture in Elkhart County. Mary Yoder fondly recalls the homemade potato chips alongside the pizza, adding a nostalgic, home-cooked charm that invites you back to familiar, comforting meals. Jacob Larger’s delight in the family-friendly portion sizes captures the restaurant’s welcoming spirit, making it a perfect choice for families looking to share a hearty meal without compromise.

For anyone seeking the best pizza in Goshen—as so many local fans attest—Paesello's Pizzeria delivers a timeless experience. The combination of perfected crust, sumptuous toppings, and heartwarming customer service creates a culinary embrace that feels both familiar and exceptional. Whether it’s a quick weeknight meal or a special treat, Paesello’s promise of authentic Italian flavors and sincere care leaves a lasting impression that enriches every bite.

Contact: 1915 Elkhart Rd, Goshen, IN 46526 | Phone: +1 574-533-2300